Kitchen
Air Fryer vs Toaster Oven
Both are small convection ovens. One is shaped for crisping and one is shaped for everything else.
By Brijon M. - Published October 17, 2026
The short answer
Buy an air fryer if the food you reheat and cook most is frozen, breaded or meant to be crisp - its small chamber and strong fan do that better and faster. Buy a toaster oven if you want one appliance that toasts, bakes, broils and reheats a pizza slice, and you can give up some crisping to get it.
Disclosure: we earn commission on qualifying purchases made through the links below, at no extra cost to you. It never changes the order of our picks - here is how that works.
They are closer than the marketing suggests
A basket air fryer is a small convection oven with a powerful fan and a perforated basket. A convection toaster oven is a larger convection oven with a wire rack. The cooking physics is the same: hot air moved quickly past food.
What differs is the ratio of fan power to chamber volume. An air fryer moves a lot of air through a small space, so the surface of the food dries and browns fast. A toaster oven moves less air through a bigger space, so it behaves more like a small conventional oven.
That single difference explains every practical consequence below. The air fryer is better at crisping and faster to preheat. The toaster oven holds more, fits a sheet pan, and does the jobs where you do not want the surface blasted dry.
The second difference is shape. A basket is deep and small; a toaster oven is wide and shallow. Food lies in one layer in a toaster oven and piles up in a basket, and piled food does not crisp.
- Air fryer: small chamber, strong fan, fast preheat, best crisping, shallow capacity.
- Toaster oven: bigger chamber, gentler fan, fits a sheet pan or a 9-inch dish, toasts properly.
- Both use far less energy than heating a full-size oven for a small meal.
- Neither fries anything. The name is marketing - it is convection.
How to read the table below
In the side-by-side that follows, the Cheap column is the basket air fryer and the Expensive column is the convection toaster oven. Prices overlap heavily in this category, so treat those labels as "compact" and "full-size" rather than as a price claim - a good toaster oven is usually the bigger purchase in both money and counter space.
Quick picks
The short version. Tap any row to jump to the full write-up, or go straight to Amazon to check the current price.
| # | Product | Best for | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | A 5-6 quart basket air fryer The size that fits a family meal, and the shape that does crisping properly. | Best for crisping | |
| 2 | A convection toaster oven Toasts, bakes, broils and reheats - one appliance instead of three. | Best all-rounder | |
| 3 | An air fryer toaster oven (combo) Does both jobs; does neither quite as well as the dedicated version. | Best if you only have room for one |
We do not print prices on this site. Every button opens the live Amazon listing so you see the real price at the moment you click. See our affiliate disclosure.
1. Best for crisping
A 5-6 quart basket air fryer
The size that fits a family meal, and the shape that does crisping properly.
- 5-6 quart basket
- Digital presets and a manual mode
- Dishwasher-safe basket and crisper plate
- Preheats in two to three minutes
Five to six quarts is the size that suits three to four people, and it is where most of the market sits for good reason - smaller baskets force two batches for a family meal, which removes the speed advantage entirely.
The reason to buy this over a toaster oven is specific: frozen chips, breaded chicken, wings, roast potatoes and reheated takeaway all come out meaningfully crisper, and in less time, than they do in a bigger chamber.
The cleaning advantage is underrated. Two dishwasher-safe parts against a toaster oven's racks, tray and baked-on interior is a weekly difference.
Our best air fryer under $100 roundup covers the models in this size class, and what size air fryer do I need works through the capacity question properly.
What you give up
It cannot toast, it will not take a sheet pan or a flat pizza slice, and it is loud. Food piled above one layer steams instead of crisping, which is the limit people hit first.
2. Best all-rounder
A convection toaster oven
Toasts, bakes, broils and reheats - one appliance instead of three.
- Fits a quarter sheet pan or a 9-inch dish
- Bake, broil, toast and convection modes
- Four to six slice toast capacity
- Usually 15-20 inches wide
If you are replacing a toaster and want to stop heating a full-size oven for two portions, this is the better purchase. It does the toaster's job, the small-batch baking job and the reheating job.
Lying food flat on a rack is the practical advantage that comes up every week: a pizza slice, four pieces of toast, a tray of vegetables, a small gratin. None of those work in a basket.
On a convection setting a toaster oven will crisp frozen food perfectly acceptably. It simply does not do it as well or as fast as a dedicated air fryer.
What you give up
Much bigger on the counter, longer preheat, and far more to clean - racks, trays and an interior that accumulates baked-on grease that an air-fryer basket never gets.
3. Best if you only have room for one
An air fryer toaster oven (combo)
Does both jobs; does neither quite as well as the dedicated version.
- Toaster-oven chamber with an air-fry mode
- Takes a sheet pan and a crisper basket
- Toast, bake, broil, air fry, often dehydrate
- One appliance instead of two
The honest middle. In a kitchen with one spare patch of counter, this is usually the right answer - and it is the reason this category now outsells both dedicated types in some segments.
You get flat-rack cooking and toast, plus an air-fry basket and a stronger fan than a plain toaster oven, which closes a reasonable part of the crisping gap.
The jobs it is best at are the ones where the dedicated machines are both mediocre: a tray of vegetables that you want browned rather than steamed, reheating a whole takeaway meal, a small batch of wings on a sheet.
What you give up
It does not crisp like a dedicated basket - more chamber means less violent airflow - and it is as big on the counter as a toaster oven. Cleaning is toaster-oven cleaning, with an extra basket.
Side by side
Which one you should buy, by what you cook
Mostly frozen and breaded food, for one or two people. Air fryer, clearly. Faster, crisper, less washing-up, smaller footprint.
You currently own a toaster and keep heating the big oven for two portions. Toaster oven. It replaces an appliance you already have rather than adding one.
You bake, even occasionally. Toaster oven. A basket cannot take a tin properly and the heat distribution is wrong for it.
You cook for four or more. Toaster oven or a large combo. A basket forces batches above about four servings, and batching erases the time advantage.
Counter space is the binding constraint and you want one appliance. The combo, with your eyes open about the crisping compromise.
You have a full-size oven you are happy using. An air fryer is the better addition, because it does the one thing your oven is genuinely bad at: crisping a small quantity fast.
The energy argument, which is real
This is one of the few appliance comparisons where running cost is a legitimate reason to buy. Both of these heat a small chamber; a full-size oven heats a very large one and takes ten to fifteen minutes to get there.
For a meal that occupies one shelf - a tray of vegetables, two chicken breasts, reheated leftovers - using a countertop appliance instead of the oven saves a meaningful amount of electricity, every time, and the saving compounds over a year of weeknights.
The air fryer edges the toaster oven here because the chamber is smaller and the preheat is shorter, but the gap between the two is small compared with the gap between either of them and a full oven.
The place the argument breaks down is batching. If you have to run an air fryer three times to feed four people, you have spent longer and used more than one pass through a toaster oven would have.
Do you need both?
Some kitchens genuinely use both, and the division of labour is clean: the toaster oven does breakfast, baking and anything that lies flat; the air fryer does frozen food and reheating.
But two appliances is two patches of counter, and the usual outcome is that one of them migrates to a cupboard within six months and never comes back. If you are not sure, buy one, use it for a season, and see what it fails at.
If you do end up buying the second one, buy it for the specific failure you experienced rather than for the feature list. "I cannot get toast" and "I cannot crisp anything" are good reasons; "it has more presets" is not.
Our best toaster oven under $100 and best air fryer under $100 roundups cover both sides at the same ceiling, and best air fryer under $50 covers the single-person tier.
Common questions
+Is an air fryer better than a toaster oven?
For crisping frozen and breaded food, yes - the small chamber and strong fan dry and brown the surface faster. For everything else a toaster oven is more useful: it toasts, bakes, broils, fits a sheet pan and takes a flat pizza slice, none of which a basket does well.
+Can a toaster oven do what an air fryer does?
On a convection setting, mostly - it will crisp frozen food acceptably, just less crisply and more slowly than a dedicated basket. The gap is about airflow per cubic inch, which is a shape problem rather than a quality problem.
+Do I need both an air fryer and a toaster oven?
Usually not. Buy one, use it for a season, and buy the second only if you hit a specific wall - no toast, or nothing crisps. Two countertop ovens is two patches of counter, and one of them typically ends up in a cupboard.
+Are air fryer toaster oven combos any good?
Yes, with a known compromise. A combo gives you flat-rack cooking, toast and a stronger fan than a plain toaster oven, but a bigger chamber means less aggressive airflow, so it does not crisp like a dedicated basket. In a one-appliance kitchen it is usually the right call.
+Does an air fryer use less electricity than an oven?
Yes, substantially, for small meals - it heats a much smaller chamber and preheats in two to three minutes rather than ten to fifteen. A toaster oven saves nearly as much. The saving disappears if you have to run the air fryer in three batches to feed everyone.
+Can you toast bread in an air fryer?
Badly. Bread sits at odd angles in a basket, browns unevenly and can get blown around by the fan. Toast is the clearest single job where a toaster oven wins outright.
Sources
Read next
Best air fryer under $100
Best Air Fryer Under $100 (October 2026)
Usable capacity and coating durability decide this category. Five picks under $100, and the wattage myth.
Best toaster oven under $100
Best Toaster Oven Under $100 (October 2026)
Four toaster ovens under $100, ranked on even heat and usable space. Plus whether the air fryer mode is worth paying for.
Kitchen
What Size Air Fryer Do I Need?
The quart figure is the basket volume, not the usable cooking area. How to size by household, and the one measurement to check instead.
Category
Kitchen
Air fryers, blenders, knives and coffee gear - the categories where spending more buys the least.
Shop by price
Under $100
The sweet spot. The only price ceiling with real search demand in all seven categories we cover.
Think we got a pick wrong, or spotted one that is out of stock or over its ceiling? Tell us - corrections go to the front of the queue.